Volume 7, Issue 2: October 2026

Have you ever felt like your favorite hobby was becoming too expensive to enjoy?

Concert tickets are appearing on resale platforms for hundreds of dollars above their original price. Trading cards purchased at retail are resurfacing online with insane markups. Products once associated with recreation and shared interests are becoming commodities in a market where enthusiasm can translate into profit.

For concertgoers, gamers and collectors, obtaining a sought-after item can mean competing with people who have no intention of keeping it. While one consumer hopes to experience a concert or complete a collection, another may see an opportunity to capitalize on the demand.

That said, the distinction between the two isn’t always clear-cut. It’s easy to paint scalpers as evil, but a reseller may depend on those transactions as a vital source of income. Meanwhile, consumers paying the markup may be struggling with expenses on their own.

When both sides have something at stake, where does entrepreneurship end and exploitation begin?

“There is nothing wrong buying something at one price and selling it at another.”

Economics professor George Lam

For students managing tuition, employment, and everyday expenses, hobbies can offer an escape from financial responsibilities. Yet limited releases and inflated second-hand market prices can transform those would-be recreational interests into another financial burden.

The issue transcends what people are willing to pay. It raises questions about access, fairness and the communities formed around the things people enjoy.

Economically, the distinction between reselling and scalping isn’t as straightforward as their reputations would suggest.

George Lam, an economics professor at Moraine Valley, explained that both practices involve purchasing products and selling them at higher prices. However, the circumstances surrounding those transactions shape how consumers perceive them.

An entrepreneur purchasing inventory assumes the possibility that a product won’t sell. A scalper typically targets merchandise with limited availability or considerable demand, anticipating that the consumers will pay more once the original supply becomes hard to obtain.

“Scalping usually has a more negative connotation because it involves purchasing limited supply or highly sought after products,” Lam said.

The prices themselves are often informed by rarity, popularity and comparable listings on marketplaces like eBay.

But scarcity doesn’t always originate with resellers.

Manufacturers may underestimate demand or produce limited quantities, creating shortages before a scalper makes a purchase. According to Lam, individuals who obtain merchandise in bulk can intensify those shortages by concentrating available inventory in fewer hands.

“Scalpers can make a situation worse by purchasing large quantities of products and leaving fewer available regular consumers,” Lam said.

Automated purchasing programs can compound imbalance, allowing professional buyers to complete transactions faster than in-person purchasing.

For consumers unable or unwilling to pay resale prices, the result can be simple: A product may technically remain available, but only at a price beyond their budget.

As collectibles gain financial value, the consequences may reach beyond affordability.

In March 2026, five Pokemon card sellers in Gage Park were allegedly robbed at gunpoint after arranging sales through Facebook marketplace.

According to FOX 32 Chicago, 23-year-old Anthony Garcia was charged with five counts of armed robbery in connection to the incidents. Police alleged that Garcia contacted sellers under the pretense of purchasing the cards before threatening them with a firearm and stealing their merchandise.

The accusations concern armed robbery, not scalping. However, the incidents reveal a vulnerability within trading valuable collectibles: products exchanged through hobbyist communities can also become an attractive target for thieves.

These concerns surfaced all the way over in Santiago, Chile.

In March 2026, 20-year-old Pokemon Card seller Dominique Olortigue Quispe disappeared. According to Chilean broadcaster TVN, investigators suspected that she had been killed in connection with an attempt to steal her trading-card collection, reportedly valued at around 6 million Chilean pesos.

Two suspects were detained in April and placed in pretrial detention. At the time of that reporting, her body had not been recovered, and the allegations hadn’t resulted in a conviction.

While neither case establishes a direct connection between scalping and violent crime, both demonstrate the risks surrounding transactions involving high-value collectibles.

A trading card may represent years of collecting, nostalgia, or shared interests among friends. To someone else, the same card may represent merchandise that can be converted into cash. The difference in perceived value can change the way people approach hobbies particularly when sellers themselves become targets.

Scalpers are usually in a very unpopular position in consumer culture. To someone waiting for a concert ticket or limited-edition product, seeing the same items listed at several times the original price can feel like being charged for somebody else’s spot in line.

But the public’s frustration with scalping doesn’t always reflect the circumstances of everyone participating in resale markets. Some sellers operate established businesses. Others trade within their communities, sell items they no longer need or purchase merchandise to supplement their income.

And while resellers may profit from transactions, they can also face risks associated with handling valuable products.

The Gage Park robberies demonstrate how an online listing can become an opportunity for theft. The victims arranged what they believed would be ordinary sales before allegedly being confronted with a firearm. Following the incidents, Chicago police advised buyers and sellers to conduct marketplace transactions at police stations.

While there’s no evidence that they were targeted specifically for scalping purposes, a question arises: How does the negative reputation surrounding scalping affect the people working within the broader resale economy?

Criticizing inflated prices isn’t the same as threatening someone’s safety. Likewise, participating in a resale business doesn’t automatically mean someone is manipulating supplies or exploiting consumers.

Behind the transactions are individuals whose relationships with collecting often began long before they considered turning their interests into a business.

At Dragon’s Den in Oak Lawn, a shared interest in collecting brought three hobbyists together to establish a business of their own. Andrew, one of the shop’s founders, described their approach as “trading one hobby for another.”

The founders came from differing collecting backgrounds, but their interests provided a common foundation for a business that could cater to more than one kind of enthusiast.

With previous experience in e-commerce, Andrew was already familiar with selling merchandise online, a practice that continues to account for most of Dragon’s Den’s business. Yet he described the shop’s purpose as something beyond simply purchasing merchandise and reselling it at a higher price.

For Andrew, the business is about “taking treasured things and giving them new life.”

Rather than limiting inventory to one category, the founders wanted to establish a space where customers with different hobbies can find something worth exploring.

Andrew explained that customers for specialized storefronts don’t always share the same interests. One person may spend an extended period browsing merchandise while the person they’re with is waiting to leave.

Dragon’s Den aims to accommodate both parties.

This approach also shapes the shop’s relationship with nearby retailers. When referring to a nearby sports-card shop, Andrew explained that both stores operate in their own respective niches rather than competing for the same customers. The objective isn’t necessarily to replace another business but to introduce customers to items and interests they might not have considered beforehand.

Still, enthusiasm doesn’t eliminate the financial calculations involved in reselling.

During a visit to the shop, a customer entered carrying two Pokémon card products and approached Eno, another founder whose interests center on trading cards.

Eno examined the merchandise’s market value before negotiating with the customer. They eventually reached a $100 agreement involving one of the items, while the second would be considered later.

The interaction offered a firsthand glimpse into how an independent collectibles retailer evaluates merchandise. Rather than assigning a price based exclusively on what an item originally cost, Eno considered its value in the current market.

“Scarcity and rarity,” he said when asked what influences the pricing of trading cards.

But those factors don’t guarantee that a collectible will maintain its value.

“Things go up, things go down, it’s just the market,” Eno explained, describing the unpredictable nature of trading cards as a “gamble.”

A card that attracts considerable demand today may struggle to find buyers tomorrow. For a business purchasing merchandise to resell, those fluctuations can represent financial opportunities as well as risks.

This uncertainty also illustrates a distinction between ordinary resale and deliberately exploiting shortages.

While some scalpers acquire large quantities of newly released merchandise with the intention of profiting from limited availability, independent collectibles shops may purchase previously owned items and return them to circulation.

At Dragon’s Den, that process is part of the shop’s purpose: helping customers discover new interests and connecting others with collectibles they may have spent years searching for.

Their approach presents another side of the resale economy, one in which purchasing and selling merchandise can help sustain a hobby rather than simply restrict access to it.

Chicago’s disputes over ticket resale stretch back decades, long before automated purchasing systems became a concern for concertgoers and sports fans.

In 2003, Chicago Sun-Times sports columnist Greg Couch investigated an arrangement involving the Chicago Cubs and Wrigley Field Premium Ticket Services, a brokerage affiliated with the team’s then-owner, the Tribune Company.

What began as a tip from one of Couch’s editors developed into an investigation of how tickets advertised at one price could reappear through a nearby brokerage for substantially more.

During a highly anticipated series between the Cubs and New York Yankees, tickets with a face value of $45 were reportedly offered for upwards of $1,000.

Couch recalled visiting the brokerage, examining its operations and trying to establish who controlled the business. The brokerage sat a short walk from Wrigley Field, but its relationship with the Cubs was not immediately apparent to customers.

One discovery came from an unlikely place: a local sign maker.

While investigating who had paid for the brokerage’s signage, Couch visited the business responsible for producing it. He recalled the sign maker searching through a box of receipts before showing him a payment record bearing the name Chicago National League Ball Club.

For Couch, the document provided evidence of a financial connection between the Cubs and the brokerage.

His investigation expanded to questions about ticket revenue, municipal taxes and whether an organization could effectively sell tickets to an affiliated business before offering them to the public at a considerable markup.

The arrangement ultimately faced a class-action lawsuit, although the Cubs and the brokerage prevailed in court. An Illinois appellate court upheld the ruling in 2006.

More than two decades later, Couch continues to distinguish between charging a high price vs. advertising one price while routing tickets through an affiliated reseller.

“I don’t care what you charge for the tickets. I just don’t like it that you’re saying you’re charging one thing and then you’re really charging something else,” Couch said during an interview. “That’s a scam.”

For Couch, the issue was never simply that Cubs tickets had become expensive. It was that fans could be led to believe they had an opportunity to purchase seats at face value when tickets were also being sold through an affiliated brokerage.

One fan’s experience remained particularly memorable.

“Things go up, things go down, it’s just the market“

Dragon’s Den owner

Couch recalled a Chicago taxi driver who had promised to take his daughter and family to a Cubs game for her birthday. Hoping to secure tickets, the man waited overnight in line, sacrificing time he otherwise could have spent working.

When he reached the ticket window, the seats he wanted were unavailable. He was directed toward the nearby brokerage, where tickets could still be purchased, but at prices beyond what he had anticipated spending.

Unable to afford admission for the entire family, the driver purchased two tickets so he could keep his promise to his daughter. What was supposed to be a family outing became a difficult financial decision.

Couch recalled that the controversy sparked anger among Cubs supporters and that the brokerage eventually needed additional security following confrontations with frustrated fans.

Although the franchise prevailed in court, he questioned who benefited from that outcome.

The taxi driver’s experience illustrated the kind of disconnect Couch believed existed between the organization and the people who continued supporting it.

More than two decades after the Cubs controversy, another ticket brokerage is facing federal scrutiny, this time over the methods allegedly used to acquire millions of tickets.

On Oct. 15, 2026, the U.S. Department of Justice and Federal Trade Commission announced a civil complaint against ticket broker REPS & Company and three executives.

Federal regulators alleged that the defendants circumvented purchasing restrictions to acquire more than 18.5 million tickets beginning in 2022, spending over $1.3 billion in the process.

According to the complaint, the operation generated at least $120.8 million in resale profits. The allegations have not been established in court.

The lawsuit concerns alleged violations of the Better Online Ticket Sales Act, commonly known as the BOTS Act. The federal law prohibits circumventing technological restrictions intended to enforce purchasing limits for online event tickets.

Ticket resale itself is not universally prohibited under federal law. The distinction lies partly in how tickets are obtained and whether purchasing restrictions are deliberately bypassed.

The REPS case differs from the Cubs controversy in both its allegations and business structure. Nevertheless, the two disputes raise a similar question: How much opportunity do ordinary buyers have when professional organizations possess the resources to acquire tickets on a scale individual consumers cannot match?

Consumer protections have evolved since Couch’s original reporting. In May 2025, a federal rule took effect requiring live-event ticket sellers to display prices that include mandatory fees upfront, subject to specified exceptions. The rule addresses pricing transparency rather than prohibiting resale markups.

Couch believes the professionalization of ticket scalping has created a marketplace in which consumers may struggle to obtain tickets without paying intermediaries.

He described modern resale brokers as part of an industry that has transformed what once happened on sidewalks and through informal transactions into established businesses.

“You can’t get the tickets at the price, because they all got all the tickets at first,” Couch said, criticizing the ability of professional buyers to acquire inventory before ordinary fans.

His concern extends beyond a particular seller or platform. He questions whether ticketing systems adequately protect consumers seeking access to entertainment without having to pay additional intermediaries.

While professional ticket brokers may operate on a massive scale, the financial incentives behind resale are also present in smaller transactions.

A product purchased during a limited release or promotional sale may command a higher price when availability becomes scarce. The potential profit depends on demand, timing and whether the reseller can find a buyer.

But profit isn’t guaranteed.

As Eno described at Dragon’s Den, collectibles fluctuate in value. What someone purchases today may command a higher price tomorrow or lose value as consumer interest shifts.

Lam emphasized that purchasing merchandise for one price and selling it for another is not inherently exploitative.

“There is nothing wrong buying something at one price and selling it at another,” Lam wrote. “That’s how many businesses operate.”

The distinction becomes more complicated when a reseller uses automated systems to acquire a substantial portion of the available inventory, potentially leaving consumers with fewer opportunities to purchase directly.

Lam also noted that retailers and manufacturers have reasons to discourage practices that frustrate loyal customers. Repeated shortages and purchasing difficulties can damage the relationship between businesses and the people supporting their products.

Resale platforms, meanwhile, can benefit through commissions and transaction fees. Higher resale prices may generate larger fees depending on how those platforms structure their charges.

Manufacturers may also receive indirect benefits from the attention surrounding popular releases, although that doesn’t mean they necessarily encourage scalping.

These competing incentives complicate the assumption that everyone participating in the market wants the same outcome.

With Black Friday approaching, discounted merchandise and limited-time promotions offer another opportunity for resellers to purchase products below their usual prices. But ordinary consumers are searching for those same bargains.

Lam explained that shoppers unable to purchase directly from a retailer may end up paying more for those same products through a secondary marketplace.

For students managing limited budgets, the difference can determine whether a hobby remains financially accessible.

And yet the existence of businesses like Dragon’s Den demonstrates that resale doesn’t always mean purchasing something before others can get their hands on it. Sometimes it means helping merchandise find another owner, allowing someone to leave behind one interest and explore another.

The resale economy encompasses more than professional ticket brokers or people purchasing products in bulk. It includes collectors trading within their communities, independent sellers supplementing their income, businesses operating established marketplaces and consumers seeking products that may no longer be available through traditional retailers.

These participants don’t necessarily share the same motivations, nor do they experience the market’s consequences equally.

For Couch, the central issue remains whether consumers receive a fair opportunity to purchase something at the advertised price.

For Lam, the economic distinction depends partly on how sellers obtain inventory and whether their practices make existing shortages worse.

And for Andrew and Eno, reselling can also be a way of keeping collectibles circulating, introducing people to unfamiliar interests and giving previously treasured items another purpose.

Their perspectives reveal a tension that extends beyond ticket sales or trading cards: Something that represents enjoyment, belonging or nostalgia to one person may represent inventory and potential income to another.

The difference is not simply whether somebody makes money from a hobby, but how that money is made and what opportunities remain for the people who enjoy it.

As another holiday shopping season approaches, consumers and resellers will continue competing for products whose value may extend far beyond their original price tags.

And when someone’s passion becomes another person’s opportunity for profit, who ultimately determines the cost of enjoying it?


featured image graphic by azalea kozlowski

Leave a Reply

Trending